Smith DNA Project Community ForumsJoin the Smith DNA Project (Official All) with a DNA Test





HOME   Search Smiths  Login/ Register
Welcome, Guest! Get involved, go to forum you want to post in for new topic or comment LOGIN

SMITH DNA PROJECT DISCUSSION FORUM     
                   Recent Queries 
      Roll Call       Recent Discussions(All Forums)   Project Updates    
                  Getting Started on Project(Trees)  Smith DNA Groups/Discussions  Latest Comments
Forums> Group DNA Discussion Forums> Smith DNA


smithsworldwide (Admin)
FAQ: YDNA tests versus Autosomal Tests

Posted by smithsworldwide in Smith DNA on June 1, 2020 Views:(221670)  Replies (0)
PostID:1903        Please Login/Register to reply to this topic


Wally Smith posted this on the Smiths DNA Project Activity Feed at FamilyTreeDNA. He, sadly, passed away over a year ago. Still love his answer so reposting it here for all to read.

********
I get this question often. OK, I’ll give you the basic overview. YDNA is passed only from father to son. It is the best way to locate potential paternal ancestors through STR matching. The STR markers mutate at a rate which allows for sorting out paternal ancestors in the genealogical time frame, say 5-10 generations back. MTDNA is passed only from mother to daughter therefore it is of no use in tracing one’s paternal line and is of limited use in finding a maternal ancestor. You would get hundreds of matches with people who have a common maternal ancestor 20.00 years ago or more. Autosomal DNA is passed down randomly from both parents, their parents and parent’s parents and so on back through history. The only way to tell which side a match may have passed through is to test many relatives with known relationships so you can compare and sort them out. There are 23 chromosomes in all humans. 1-22 are autosomal DNA, 23 is special, in that it is the one where you get your XDNA. A female has no YDNA because the father passes his XDNA that he got from his mother to daughters only. She gets X from both parents. The son gets X from mother and Y form father. So in summary, Yes, you may get some benefit by testing your autosomal DNA, but the only way to really prove a paternal match is to test a known male descendant of the direct line male to male from the earliest known ancestor to the male testee and hope for matches with someone who has a well documented tree and go from there.
-Wally Smith




To post a new topic, go to the Smith DNA Project Discussion Forum list, above, or the Smith DNA Groups/Discussions and find the forum best suited for you and you will then see NEW TOPIC when logged on. You may leave a comment for this post when logged on

Search All Community (keyword):
        
If you need assistance from an administrator or wish to suggest a change, please send an email to info@smithsworldwide.org or use "Suggest a Change" on any given ancestor 

Latest 4 Posts

Nehemiah Smith origins
(Smith DNA Forum)

September 28, 2023
mrmhsmith
Smith DNA Project Update: Email replies will be slow or not at all till October 4
(Smith DNA Project Updates Forum)

September 17, 2023
smithsworldwide
(admin)
New Member John Smith b 1743 (Scotland) m Barbara Sibbald
(Smith DNA Project Updates Forum)

September 15, 2023
smithsworldwide
(admin)
New Member- George Matthew Smith b 1863 Eng m Maude Soliday
(Smith DNA Project Updates Forum)

September 15, 2023
smithsworldwide
(admin)

Latest 2 Comments

Latest Comments
Never a bomb. This whole project is based on trying to figure out errors and true lines of descent. If someone is wrong in who they believe is the early ancestor, and that can be proven, it's a g....read more.....
September 11, 2023
In reply to Christian C (Columbus) Smith

smithsworldwide
(admin)
See related comments here

....read more.....

September 6, 2023
In reply to Christoph and Grundling

smithsworldwide
(admin)

Smith DNA Project


SEND YOUR TREE
or send a direct line gedcom to your early Smith
Come Join Us at the Smith Official DNA Project at FamilyTreeDNA! Join Smith Official DNA Project
Ancestry Autosomal tester? TRANSFER your results

Smith DNA Project-Community Forums